A Christian street preacher Shaun O’Sullivan has been unanimously cleared of ‘religiously-aggravated intentional harassment’ by a Crown Court jury.
Despite the acquittal, the case leaves behind troubling questions about the state of free speech, policing, the rising power of untested ‘hate claims’ and the real harassment of preachers by His Majesty’s Constabulary.
Mr O’Sullivan, 36, supported by the Christian Legal Centre, had been charged under the Crime and Disorder Act 1998. His alleged offence? Saying phrases such as “We love the Jews,” taking issue with “Jew haters,” and “Palestine lovers”, while preaching in Swindon town centre on 15 September 2024.
A Muslim family told police they felt targeted because they were wearing hijabs. Before any evidence was reviewed, a 999 call-handler immediately labelled the incident a “hate crime”, a decision made without factual basis, corroboration, or investigation.
The case was pursued during heightened tensions near the one-year anniversary of the 7 October attacks and amid frequent pro-Palestine demonstrations. Yet in court, the prosecution’s foundation crumbled:
No audio evidence. No video evidence. CCTV showing only seconds of passing contact with no confrontation. Witness accounts contradicting each other on key details.
The jury saw the truth plainly. The case should never have been brought.
This incident echoes earlier controversies in which police rapidly escalated non-criminal speech into full investigations, such as the arrest of street evangelist David Little in 2019/b> and the wrongful detention of Pastor John Sherwood in 2021, both later cleared. Each case raises the same question: Is biblical speech becoming a policed category in modern Britain?
John 7:24 Judge not according to the appearance, but judge righteous judgement.
Oppose Islamophobia Definition →
The flaws exposed in court
Under cross-examination by solicitor advocate Michael Phillips, the complainant conceded that:
“She had not heard the full message; Her interpretation was shaped by personal views on Gaza. She was upset partly because Mr O’Sullivan “spoke directly to us.”
The defence argued that any statements formed part of a general theological message, consistent with British traditions of public evangelism—not personal abuse.
Expert witness Dr Martin Parsons, a respected scholar of Christian and Islamic theology, delivered critical insight:
Street preaching is historically protected in British constitutional development. Criminalising religious expression undermines Articles 9, 10 and 11 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
The alleged comments are religious opinions, not hatred. Current political climate has dangerously blurred the line between criticism of ideas and hatred of people.
He further noted theological realities often ignored in public debate, including Qur’anic verses (e.g., Q5:51) historically contributing to anti-Jewish sentiment within Islamic tradition context crucial to understanding the preacher’s message.
Meanwhile, the Crown relied almost entirely on the family’s perception, a trend increasingly seen in UK policing, where a “hate incident” can be recorded solely on the basis of subjective feeling, regardless of evidence.
2 Corinthians 4:5 For we preach not ourselves, but Christ Jesus the Lord…
Watch this video if you missed it.
Join or Support Christian Voice →
A life transformed and a liberty tested
Mr O’Sullivan’s own testimony moved the courtroom. Once immersed in violence and crime, he encountered Christ and everything changed. He now dedicates his life to proclaiming hope in public spaces, offering the same mercy that delivered him.
“I was once lost, but Christ changed everything,” he said after the verdict. “My heart is to share the good news and love all people. I never intended harm.”
The trial lasted six days and cost the taxpayer an estimated £20,000,a heavy price for a case without evidence.
Meanwhile, in Wales, a school was criticised and investigated for promoting evangelical Christianity to its pupils.The school was accused of ‘promoting creationism’.
This verdict joins a growing list of legal victories exposing overreach:
Hatun Tash, repeatedly arrested for preaching at Speakers’ Corner, the McArthur bakery case, a landmark UK decision on compelled speech.
Together, these cases form a pattern: Christian expression is still legal, but the pressure to silence it is mounting.
Acts 5:29 We ought to obey God rather than men.
Return to the UK’s Christian Constitution →
What this verdict means for Britain
This case should serve as a wake-up call to police, lawmakers, and the British public. The principle at stake was never merely about one preacher, it was about the right of believers to speak openly, Biblically, and without fear.
If Britain continues down a path where perception outweighs evidence, political sensitivities override truth,and biblical conviction becomes treated as hostility, then the fundamental freedoms carved out by our Christian heritage will slowly erode. But for now, a vital line has held.
A jury has spoken, and a preacher walks free.
The verdict reaffirms what Scripture has long taught: light drives out darkness, truth withstands accusation, and no earthly authority can silence the Gospel when God has commissioned it.
May this case strengthen the resolve of every believer who feels pressure to remain silent.
May it remind the Church that public proclamation is not merely a tradition—it is a calling.
And may Britain remember the liberties it inherited before they slip quietly away.
Ask us to come and speak at your church →
Read and Pray: Psa 118:9; 146:3; Prov 14:34; Micah 6:8; Matthew 5:10 Rom 3:13.
Pray: For street preachers. Pray for our leaders to lead in righteousness and the fear of the lord.Pray for restoration in the United Kingdom.
Previous Articles
Charles: Synagogue Attack ‘Out of the Blue’? →
Croydon Street Preacher Confronted by Police →
‘Street Preaching is Legal‘ ! →
Muslims slaughter Christians in Nigeria →
American evangelist arrested in Dundee Scotland →
Police disrupt London street worship →
Support us!
We appreciate your support; it enables our research and helps us inform your prayers.
So click below to support Christian Voice and stand up for the King of kings
Or fill in the form below to keep in touch:
Click on the social media links below to share this post:
